Breast is best
March 3rd, 2010There is something that you will not be aware of if you are not a parent: how people choose to feed their children is a frighteningly controversial topic. I never knew this until I got pregnant, and it became clear from a brief overview of parenting forums that there is a war raging between breastfeeders and formula feeders, and it is impossible to be too judgmental of the Other Side.
I find this whole thing astonishing. Surely if your child is healthy, how you get it to grow and thrive is immaterial? Why should I give a flying fuck whether the woman next to me in the under 1s group gives her child a bottle of formula? Still, there is much hoo hah on the interweb about women who do not breastfeed, and whether their reasons for not doing so are good enough.
The thing is, and no-one tells you this until you try it, is that breastfeeding is hard. Really, really hard.
At my NCT ante-natal classes we had a whole session dedicated to breastfeeding. A lovely woman came to talk to us about how breast is best, and really 99.9% of women are capable of breastfeeding. Apparently those who say they can’t are either wimps or deluding themselves. Sure, some women get mastitis, or thrush, or chapped nipples, but it’s easy to get over those minor inconveniences – they are rare, you are told. We received endless information about ‘latching on’ and different holds. Breastfeeding shouldn’t hurt if the latch is right. Chapped nipples? Just put lanolin on them and they’ll be better in no time.
After one week of breastfeeding, I wanted to hunt down that sanctimonious cow and take a cheese grater to her nipples. What would have been useful would have been more information about the support available, because without the many, many people who helped me over the course of five excruciating and emotionally draining weeks, I would have given the whole thing up, invested in a 10 gallon tin of formula, and never looked back.
There’s nothing wrong with investing in a 10 gallon tin of formula of course – it’s just that with all the propaganda flying about, the insidious judgmentalism and negative connotations in the press and in government policy about formula feeding, you feel that to resort to formula is to materially harm your baby’s chances of a decent future. The guilt is horrific. You feel like a failure – you’ve failed as a woman, and you’ve failed as a mother.
I struggled through breastfeeding, which at times was more like a horror movie (blood, pain, ripping flesh, screams) than the beautiful bonding experience I had expected. I didn’t even get mastitis or thrush, thank heaven. My boobs were simply shredded, rather than infected. I’m glad now that I didn’t give up, but at times I feared for my sanity. It would have made things so much easier if I hadn’t been racked with guilt and regret at the thought of giving up and resorting to a bottle. In the end a breastpump and a standby stock of formula saved me from chucking my baby across the room every time she wanted to eat.
My experience isn’t even uncommon. Everyone I spoke to at the breastfeeding support group had had some nature of problem. It infuriates me, however, that I wasn’t aware of this before I gave birth. I understand that people might not want to put others off, but had I known what might be in store, I would have been able to prepare myself emotionally. As it was, I spent the better part of 6 weeks in tears of pain, guilt and frustration.
Now, at 10 weeks, things are pretty much a walk in the park. Breastfeeding is cheap and easy. Hungry baby? No probs. Just whop out a boob and bingo. No mixing of formula, no sterilising bottles. It’s also turned into the lovely bonding experience that I expected.
Choosing to continue breastfeeding my daughter was entirely up to me. I wouldn’t judge anyone who chose to give up, or not to try in the first place – it’s none of my business. Far too much importance is placed on breastfeeding to the detriment of many people’s mental health.
What I’m trying to say is this: if you are reading this because you are considering giving up breastfeeding, don’t feel guilty about it. I guarantee it will be worth it if you carry on, but if you don’t, so what? Your child will not suffer, and neither should you.
That is all.

